ATLAS
← Back to News and Insights

New Jersey co-leads 44 AGs against CFTC prediction-market rules

3 min

The interim rule is already effective; a proposal would classify sports and election event contracts as swaps, putting state safeguards at issue.

LinkedIn Post

New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport co-led a bipartisan coalition of 44 attorneys general opposing two Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) rules on sports wagering, election betting and similar prediction-market products, according to a 20 November announcement. The coalition filed comments this week arguing that the rules would allow the CFTC to regulate those products exclusively and override states' authority to license gambling and impose consumer safeguards.

For gambling operators and prediction-market platforms, the dispute concerns the regulatory perimeter, not only which agency receives reports. The coalition says CFTC treatment could allow platforms to operate without state licensing, age restrictions and responsible-gambling protections, while encouraging traditional sportsbooks to reorganise as prediction markets. The interim rule is in effect, but the companion proposal is not yet final.

Two definitions, one fault line

The interim final rule excludes “casino-style gambling products” from the federal definition of a swap. Its conditions include that the provider must be licensed or authorised under state or tribal law, acting within the scope of that authorisation, and that the product must not trade on a board of trade, exchange, swap execution facility or another market where trades are executed multilaterally or individually negotiated.

That preserves a carve-out for licensed sportsbook and casino products that meet the rule's provider and product tests. It does not, however, settle the status of event contracts traded on federally regulated markets or products in which users trade against one another.

The companion proposal would add event contracts, including contracts based on sports, politics, cultural events and weather, to the swap definition. The CFTC's approach would therefore distinguish between gambling products backed by a house and contracts traded as financial-market instruments, even where both expose users to the outcome of a sporting event.

The New Jersey coalition says the distinction would let the CFTC displace state gambling law. The CFTC's position is that federally regulated prediction markets fall within its exclusive derivatives jurisdiction. That remains contested, not an established ruling.

Atlas reads the fight as a classification change with direct compliance consequences: a product's structure and venue could determine whether a firm needs state gambling approvals and controls or instead falls within the CFTC's federal market framework.

The states' legal case

The coalition argues that regulating gambling and protecting residents from gambling-related harms are traditional state police powers. It says the CFTC regulates financial markets and has no legal authority to address those harms, and that the agency skipped required rulemaking steps and exceeded the authority Congress granted it.

Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, whose office announced a related filing on 18 November, said: “A sports bet isn’t a derivative just because the CFTC says so.” The Ohio-led release also says the coalition challenges the rule's adoption with only one commissioner serving, arguing that the CFTC lacked the required quorum.

The New Jersey announcement follows Ohio's description of 43 state attorneys general and the District of Columbia opposing the sports-swaps proposal. New Jersey counts the participants as 44 attorneys general and extends the challenge to the interim rule as well as the proposal.

New Jersey has separately asked the US Supreme Court to hear its case against Kalshi, with support from 39 states, the District of Columbia and 146 tribal nations and organisations. The state says most federal courts to consider the issue have rejected the view that prediction markets offering sports betting are exempt from state law.

The New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement issued Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter on 27 March 2025 over alleged unauthorised sports wagering in the state. The CFTC's response has also become more direct. On 13 November it sued Louisiana after a state court order affecting more than 30 companies connected with CFTC-regulated derivatives. The Commission said Louisiana was the 12th state it had sued to defend its claimed exclusive jurisdiction.

The immediate regulatory positions are therefore different. The interim rule is already operative, while the sports and election event-contract proposal remains in the rulemaking process. Both documents provide for comments within 30 days after Federal Register publication.

Official source: njoag.gov
GamblingGambling Regulatory Landscape

Permanent link to this Atlas analysis

Continue with coverage connected by market, topic and operating context.

Continue with Atlas

Move from this development into the relevant research, comparison and workflow.